Skip to content
Beyond Lifespan

Mediterranean, Keto, Vegan, Paleo and Carnivore: Five Diets Compared

2 Doctors on Longevity & Biohacking

52 Min.Episode 31
Cover of the episode "Mediterranean, Keto, Vegan, Paleo and Carnivore: Five Diets Compared"

Listen to the episode

0:00–:–
Download MP3

Audio straight from the podcast feed. Your listening position is saved in this browser.

Summary

The episode at a glance

This summary was generated automatically by AI from the episode transcript and translated into English. It may contain errors or omissions and does not replace medical advice.

In this episode, Mario and Max explore five popular diets: vegan, keto, paleo, carnivore, and Mediterranean. They analyze the scientific evidence, benefits and drawbacks, and how to put each diet into practice in everyday life. They highlight that avoiding ultra-processed foods is the most important common denominator of a healthy diet, regardless of which approach you choose.

Key Takeaways

  • 01One in five deaths worldwide is linked to poor diet, making nutrition a crucial factor in health and longevity.
  • 02The Mediterranean diet, rich in vegetables, legumes, fish, and olive oil, has the strongest research base and is associated with significantly lower all-cause and cardiovascular mortality.
  • 03If you follow a ketogenic diet, which is extremely low in carbohydrates and high in fat, pay attention to your fat sources (preferably unsaturated) and ensure adequate electrolyte intake, as LDL cholesterol can rise.
  • 04A vegan diet can be very healthy, but you need to pay particular attention to your intake of vitamin B12, omega-3 fatty acids (EPA/DHA), and protein to avoid deficiencies.
  • 05Paleo, the "Stone Age diet," excludes grains, dairy products, and processed foods. It is a viable but often unnecessarily restrictive way of eating.
  • 06The most important factor shared by all healthy eating patterns is a focus on unprocessed foods. The degree of processing often matters more than the specific diet.
  • 07Meat substitutes are not inherently healthy, as they are often ultra-processed and contain many additives.
  • 08Regardless of your diet, it is important to get enough protein and fiber.

In detail

The Mediterranean diet is considered the best-researched healthy eating pattern and the easiest to put into practice. It is based on plenty of vegetables, legumes, fish, seafood, and olive oil as the main source of fat. Studies show that it significantly reduces all-cause mortality and the risk of cardiovascular disease. It is important not to confuse it with modern Italian cuisine centered on pizza and pasta.

The ketogenic diet aims to put your body into a state of ketosis through a drastic reduction in carbohydrates (less than 50 g/day) and a high fat intake (70–80%), so that fat rather than glucose serves as the primary energy source. This can help with weight loss and blood sugar regulation, but it carries a risk of increased LDL cholesterol and requires careful selection of fat sources (preferably plant-based) as well as replacement of lost electrolytes.

A vegan diet can be very healthy when it is based on unprocessed foods such as vegetables, fruit, and whole grains. Getting enough of certain nutrients is a challenge. Vitamin B12 must be supplemented, and you also need to ensure an adequate intake of plant protein (which has lower bioavailability) and omega-3 fatty acids (EPA/DHA).

The paleo diet is based on the presumed diet of hunter-gatherers and therefore excludes grains, dairy products, and processed foods. It focuses on meat, fish, vegetables, fruit, and nuts. At its core, this eating pattern is a restrictive version of the principle "more vegetables, fewer processed foods" and has been less thoroughly studied than other diets.

The carnivore diet consists exclusively of animal products such as meat, fish, and eggs. It is extremely nutrient-dense but provides no fiber and often leads to a drastic rise in cholesterol levels. Scientific data on its long-term effects are almost entirely lacking.

What you can actually do

  • Whatever diet you follow, focus primarily on how processed your food is. Choose foods that are as close to their natural state as possible.
  • Plan at least one meal a day made entirely from unprocessed, single-ingredient foods (e.g., a piece of fish, potatoes, and vegetables).
  • Make sure each main meal provides enough protein and includes a source of fiber to help you feel full and give your body the nutrients it needs.
  • If you follow a vegan diet, make sure you supplement vitamin B12 and have your levels checked regularly.

Mentioned in this episode

Vitamin B12
An essential vitamin that is absent from a purely plant-based diet and therefore must be supplemented if you follow a vegan diet.
LDL cholesterol
Can rise sharply on high-fat diets such as keto and carnivore, posing a risk for cardiovascular disease. Choosing unsaturated rather than saturated fat sources can help limit the increase.
Omega-3 fatty acids (EPA/DHA)
Important fatty acids that are generally present in plant sources only as a precursor (ALA), which has a low conversion rate. These deserve particular attention if you follow a vegan diet.
DASH diet
Stands for "Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension," a diet designed to lower high blood pressure. It is very similar to the Mediterranean diet but places additional emphasis on reducing salt intake.
Degree of processing
The key common denominator: ultra-processed foods should be avoided in all diets, as they are often a cause of excessive calorie intake and health problems.

What this episode is about

Five popular diets take very different approaches to healthy eating—but how do they compare for longevity? Mario and Max discuss Mediterranean, ketogenic, vegan, Paleo and carnivore diets, weighing the evidence, nutritional trade-offs and everyday practicality. They explain why processing levels matter, answer whether vegetarians can build muscle, and share a simple whole-food meal strategy built around protein and fiber.

Links and sources mentioned

    Links and resources

    Share episode

    Related episodes

    Cover of the episode "Anna Kraft on MS & Fatigue: Nutrition, Pacing & Supplements"
    Nutrition·Episode 28

    Anna Kraft on MS & Fatigue: Nutrition, Pacing & Supplements

    In her early thirties, a multiple sclerosis diagnosis suddenly changed sports journalist Anna Kraft’s life. Mario and Max speak with her about how she manages chronic fatigue through a radical dietary change, targeted pacing, and comprehensive blood testing. The two physicians also assess the risks of vitamin overdoses and explain the three fundamental pillars of healthy longevity.

    63 Min.